Background to Lightroom
Let’s start by comparing the two desktop versions of Lightroom.
Lightroom Classic vs Lightroom CC
When Adobe released Lightroom CC, they appeared to be moving in a new direction. The new program was cloud-based rather than desktop-based. Cloud-based software was the future. But Lightroom Classic remains popular, and Adobe continues to support the program. You can sync Collections created in Lightroom Classic to the cloud. They are available across all versions of the program. Currently, the two programs co-exist. Let’s compare them.
Both CC and Lightroom Classic are desktop programs. They share features but are not the same. At first, Lightroom CC did not have as many tools as Lightroom Classic. Adobe has added most of these tools in later versions, but some features are different by design.
Import & Catalogue
First, the programs look different. The layout of the desktop and the location of the tools is different. In Lightroom CC, Add Photos replaces Import Photos. Also, the catalogue structure is missing. You store your photos in the cloud rather than on physical media. This is one of the primary differences. Both programs have access to the Creative Cloud, but CC only uses cloud storage. When importing images, there are some missing metadata features in the CC version.
The module organisation system in Lightroom Classic is missing from Lightroom CC. Most photographers do not miss the Map, Book, Slideshow, Print, and Web modules. Lightroom CC simplifies the Library and Develop modules. The tools from the Library module are on the bottom right toolbar. The editing tools are in the upper right.
- Tone Curve
- Colour Grading
- Lens Corrections
Individual tools may be in different panels. Texture, Clarity, and Dehaze are in the Basic panel in Lightroom Classic. In CC, these tools are in the Effects panel, along with Vignette and Grain. Temperature and Tint have also moved. They are now in the Colour panel. To some photographers, the new organisation makes more sense.
The Crop tool and presets for selective edits are in the Basic panel in Lightroom Classic. In Lightroom CC, they are on the right side. The Crop tool includes helpful quick-flip options. But you can no longer draw a line across a horizon to straighten an image. The Spot Removal tool is called Healing Brush in CC, and selective edit tools are similar across both versions. It is unclear if selective edit presets can be saved in CC, which is a great time-saving feature in Lightroom Classic.
In Lightroom CC, extra features are located in optional panels. For instance, to access presets, click the Preset button in the bottom right. A second column opens to the right of your image. This column reduces my working space.
Missing Elements from Lightroom CC
Some missing elements in CC keep my workflow in Lightroom Classic. For instance, masking features are missing. These features are used when sharpening and making selective edits. Lightroom Classic also has photo merge tools. The HDR and Panorama merge features are basic, but they work for many photos. Also, keywording in Lightroom Classic is more custom.
Lightroom CC uses AI to automatically keyword images. This feature is terrific! For example, you can search “sunrise” and pictures of sunrises appear even if they are not keyworded. But it is disconcerting not to see the keywords listed, and they do not export in the file’s metadata.
Like Lightroom Classic, CC uses hotkeys to speed up functions. Some are the same; others are different. The hotkey “W” in both programs opens the white balance eyedropper. But “C” in Lightroom Classic compares two images, a feature absent from CC. In the newer program, this hotkey copies settings. The “J” in Lightroom Classic has no functionality. In CC, it shows a clipping mask. You can relearn hotkeys, but differences between programs suggest a fundamental restructuring.
Lightroom Mobile App vs Lightroom CC
The Lightroom mobile app is like Lightroom CC but adds some tools from Lightroom Classic.
Adobe rearranged tools for the mobile experience. Select what you want to do from the drop-down menu in the upper left corner. You can edit, rate & review, add keywords, or add a title or a caption.
When editing an image, the toolbar appears along the bottom of the app. This gives you the same functions as the right-hand column in Lightroom CC. Selective edits, like the radial filter and healing brush, are in the main toolbar. Presets, a separate panel in CC, are also on the main toolbar in the app. Presets and profiles sync across the various versions of Lightroom. If you add presets to Lightroom Classic, they will also appear in CC and the app.
The names of tools and panels in the app are the same as Lightroom CC. The general organisation is also like CC. For instance, the Effects panel contains Texture, Clarity, Dehaze, Vignette, and Grain. But the app includes adjustments found only in Lightroom Classic. For instance, you can control the size and roughness of the grain.
Hotkeys are not available in the app. But there are some gestural shortcuts found under the settings menu. The app takes advantage of the touch screen capabilities of your mobile device. For instance, you click and drag to change the size of a brush. When rating and reviewing images, a swipe up flags the photo, a swipe down rejects it.
The export options are similar between Lightroom CC and the app. One interesting feature included in CC and the app is the ability to Share Edit. This lets other photographers see how you have edited your work. The app also allows you to show a slideshow of your images. This feature is under the three-dot icon.
The mobile app also includes a camera with its own set of features. One advantage of using the Lightroom camera is that it creates raw files and saves them as DNG files. There is an HDR option along with simulated long exposure and shallow depth of field.
The app has an organisational structure like Lightroom CC. But sometimes tools found only in Lightroom Classic appear in the app.
Ligtroom Browser Version
There is also a browser-based version of Lightroom, found at https://clk.tradedoubler.com/click?p=264355&a=3209787&g=22804962&url=https://lightroom.adobe.com/. In many respects, this version looks like an incomplete Lightroom CC.
The web version of Lightroom includes the Edit and Crop panels. But selective edits and healing brush are absent. The Edits panel includes the Light, Color, and Effects panels. They are almost exactly as they appear in CC. But it does not include the Detail, Optics, and Geometry panels.
You can share from the browser version, but the options are limited. An addition to both the app and the browser-based version is the “Choose Best Photos” option. Lightroom analyses the images in an album and selects the best. It is unclear how the AI chooses images. But you can adjust the quality threshold to select more or fewer photos.
The benefits of this version are not immediately clear. A Lightroom Classic user could use this version to create links and share albums with clients. Creating a synced Collection in Lightroom Classic will appear in the browser version. You can then share the album from the browser version.